INQ328

TitleLong
Independent Review of National Natural Disaster Governance Arrangements: Final Report
INQAuthor
Dr Robert Glasser
Year
InquiryType
DisasterType
State
Status

Recommendations for this Inquiry

INQ-ref REC-UID CODE SubCode SrcNUM Recommendation
INQ328 REC328-4346 A - Responsibility 21 - Role of Commonwealth Government Recommendation 1

The National Cabinet should take a leadership role in coordinating resilience initatives across the Federation

INQ328 REC328-4362 C - Response 7 - Inter-agency communication Recommendation 17

The government members of ANZEMC should be senior officials (Commissioners, Deputy Secretaries or Heads of Agencies) from agencies that have the lead jurisdictional responsibility for preparedness and response and resilience and recovery.

INQ328 REC328-4363 C - Response 7 - Inter-agency communication Recommendation 18

Each jurisdiction should be allowed a maximum of three senior officials on ANZEMC to enable the inclusion of these jurisdictional responsibilities (see Appendix F for Summary of State and Territory responsibilities).

INQ328 REC328-4364 C - Response 7 - Inter-agency communication Recommendation 19

ANZEMC should meet four times each year, including twice face-to- face, with one of the in-person meetings devoted predominantly to “Disaster Resilience and Recovery.” The face-to-face meetings should be preceded by an opportunity for the ANZEMC members to meet informally.

INQ328 REC328-4365 E - Agency Organisation 37 - Funding Recommendation 20

The Commonwealth should allocate a significant budget to ANZEMC to support implementation of the NEMMM’s five priorities for action.

INQ328 REC328-4366 C - Response 15 - Inter-service cooperation Recommendation 21

ANZEMC should establish time-limited, flexible task forces, reporting directly to ANZEMC, to implement NEMMM’s five priorities for action and essential other initiatives, comprised of diverse membership (e.g., government, private sector, academia, civil society), determined by the requirements of

INQ328 REC328-4367 C - Response 15 - Inter-service cooperation Recommendation 22

The current ANZEMC Sub-committees and other subsidiary bodies should be reconceptualised as “communities of practice” and important sources of expert advice, rather than as national governance bodies.

INQ328 REC328-4368 C - Response 15 - Inter-service cooperation Recommendation 23

ANZEMC should map out the many existing time-limited working groups and reference and advisory groups and the communities of practice, to identify which are no longer required and should be discontinued, which should continue and be officially sanctioned by ANZEMC, which should continue as inform

INQ328 REC328-4369 C - Response 15 - Inter-service cooperation Recommendation 24

ANZEMC’s Terms of Reference should be amended to reflect the recommendations above.

INQ328 REC328-4370 C - Response 15 - Inter-service cooperation Recommendation 25

NEMA with CCOSC should investigate ways to better integrate and align CCOSC and the NRSC with the national coordination capacity.

INQ328 REC328-4371 A - Responsibility 21 - Role of Commonwealth Government Recommendation 26

The Commonwealth should identify the longer-term resourcing and organisational requirements to build coordination capacity for relief and early recovery.

INQ328 REC328-4372 E - Agency Organisation 37 - Funding Recommendation 27

In light of the fact that NEMA is a small agency with far fewer options than much larger government departments to reallocate resources for their Ministerial Council Secretariats, the Commonwealth should consider supplementing NEMA’s funding for this purpose.

INQ328 REC328-4373 E - Agency Organisation 37 - Funding Recommendation 28

The Commonwealth should allocate a significant program budget to the Ministerial Council to enable effective implementation of its five national priorities for action.

INQ328 REC328-4374 E - Agency Organisation 37 - Funding Recommendation 29

Jurisdictions should also contribute resourcing to implement the priorities for action, such as contributions in-kind and other funding, proportionate to the size of the jurisdiction.

INQ328 REC328-4361 C - Response 7 - Inter-agency communication Recommendation 16

The ANZEMC workplan and meeting agendas should be explicitly organised under two headings: “Disaster Resilience and Recovery” and “Preparedness and Capabilities Policy”.

INQ328 REC328-4360 C - Response 7 - Inter-agency communication Recommendation 15

ANZEMC’s core mission should be narrowed to:
1) Supporting the NEMMM, particularly to identify its five priorities for action and ensuring they are implemented; and

INQ328 REC328-4347 A - Responsibility 21 - Role of Commonwealth Government Recommendation 2

The National Cabinet should task Ministerial Councils to include resilience activities in their annual reporting, with the NEMMM contribution focussing on natural hazards.

INQ328 REC328-4348 A - Responsibility 38 - Agency/Department Reporting Recommendation 3

The First Secretaries, on behalf of the National Cabinet, should oversee (via a subordinate Deputy Secretaries Group) the development of an annual Australian National Resilience Report (ANRR) that combines the Ministerial Council resilience reporting, existing resilience strategies in jurisdictio

INQ328 REC328-4349 A - Responsibility 38 - Agency/Department Reporting Recommendation 4

The ANRR should be a National Cabinet product focused on climate and disaster risk as well as other key resilience risks agreed by the Commonwealth and the jurisdictions.

INQ328 REC328-4350 A - Responsibility 38 - Agency/Department Reporting Recommendation 5

The Commonwealth together with the States and Territories should identify their shared high-level resilience objectives and develop indicators to monitor national progress in achieving them. The ANRR should also provide annual updates on progress in achieving the objectives.

INQ328 REC328-4351 A - Responsibility 38 - Agency/Department Reporting Recommendation 6

At least once each year, coinciding with the production of the ANRR, the National Cabinet should evaluate progress in bolstering national resilience.

INQ328 REC328-4352 A - Responsibility 21 - Role of Commonwealth Government Recommendation 7

The Commonwealth Government should direct the Secretaries Board to ensure the overall coherence and efficiency of the Government’s resilience efforts, spanning both the climate adaptation/disaster risk reduction and the national security domains.

INQ328 REC328-4353 A - Responsibility 38 - Agency/Department Reporting Recommendation 8

The next iteration of NEMMM’s Five Priorities for Action should be explicit and measurable, bold but achievable and focused on national outcomes, rather than outputs. They should:
- Be formulated in terms such as “By 2026 we will have established…which will have reduced…”, etc.

INQ328 REC328-4354 B - Preparedness 39 - Disaster Risk Management Recommendation 9

NEMMM’s leading role in the wider national resilience effort should focus on disaster risk reduction, and it should engage as a core stakeholder in a wider range of other resilience issues. It should further elaborate this focus with respect to:

INQ328 REC328-4355 B - Preparedness 39 - Disaster Risk Management Recommendation 10

Each NEMMM agenda should have a standing item on disaster risk reduction/resilience and at least one full meeting each year should be devoted to Disaster Resilience and Recovery.

INQ328 REC328-4356 C - Response 7 - Inter-agency communication Recommendation 11

NEMMM should co-convene a joint Ministerial Council meeting with climate change adaptation ministers to promote greater coherence between NEMMM’s resilience work and climate adaptation—two key components of a future national resilience strategy. This should be a face-to-face meeting.

INQ328 REC328-4357 C - Response 7 - Inter-agency communication Recommendation 12

NEMMM agendas should ensure that discussion of urgent tactical challenges don’t crowd-out consideration of the strategic challenges.

INQ328 REC328-4358 C - Response 7 - Inter-agency communication Recommendation 13

Given the importance of NEMMM’s work, meetings should occur quarterly and be in-person at least twice yearly, be of sufficient length to allow for issues to be properly canvassed and discussed and be preceded by an opportunity for the NEMMM members to meet informally alone together.

INQ328 REC328-4359 A - Responsibility 38 - Agency/Department Reporting Recommendation 14

NEMMM’s Terms of Reference should be amended to reflect the recommendations above.

INQ328 REC328-4375 A - Responsibility 21 - Role of Commonwealth Government Recommendation 30

It is appropriate that NEMA should be able to draw on its administered funding to support implementation across jurisdictions of projects associated with delivering the five national priorities for action. NEMA should explore this option.